Program Evaluation as Contested: Can We Navigate Tensions for Transformative Practice?

In this presentation, our speakers will explore how varying organizational contexts can invite or constrain possibilities for evaluation work – particularly in relation to how evaluation can contribute to system transformation and social justice. They will share recent research on the tensions that evaluators in the academic health sciences routinely encounter as they conduct evaluation while navigating accreditation and other institutional demands.

Description

Program evaluation is routinely recommended as a practice that is essential to enhancing the quality of educational offerings. However, there is limited reflection on how evaluation is positioned within our system nor on the contested (prone-to-conflict) nature of evaluation work. In this presentation, our speakers will explore how varying organizational contexts can invite or constrain possibilities for evaluation work – particularly in relation to how evaluation can contribute to system transformation and social justice. They will share recent research on the tensions that evaluators in the academic health sciences routinely encounter as they conduct evaluation while navigating accreditation and other institutional demands. The talk also raises provocative questions about the accountabilities of evaluation in the academic health sciences, while remaining grounded in the day-to-day realities of practicing evaluation in healthcare and health professions education.

Ultimately, our speakers provide unique theoretical perspectives on contemporary program evaluation and share practical insights on transformative practices

Additional Info

Moderator: Deena Hamza

Presenters

Dr. Betty Onyura is the Associate Director Evaluation and Knowledge Mobilization at the Centre for Faculty Development, and Assistant Professor in the Department of Family and Community Medicine. She identifies strongly as a scientist practitioner, who collaborates on diverse evaluation projects while leading a SSHRC-funded program of research focused on program evaluation as a social and scientific enterprise. Her research includes ongoing projects on evaluation ethics, evaluation and harm, and evaluation tensions, as well as work to advance evaluation methods and frameworks. Betty is a committed Credentialed Evaluator with the Canadian Evaluation Society and sits on the Board of Directors of the Society’s regional (Ontario) chapter.

Yasser Ismail is a Credentialed Evaluator (C.E.) whose work spans the continuum of evaluation, evaluation-driven policy and program design, and, evaluation-driven learning and development. Currently completing his Doctorate of Education (EdD) at the University of Western Ontario, Yasser’s current praxis inquiry is on the use of evaluation-driven approaches for building health professional capacity for critically-reflexive, culturally safe and structurally competent clinical engagement. In his role as the inaugural Manager of Program Evaluation & Knowledge Translation and a member of the strategic leadership team at Casey House, Yasser is particularly passionate about situating evaluation as transformative change practice to influence socially-just clinical practice at the point-of-care and to influence structural change for the hospital at large.

Rounds Details

Best Practice in Education Rounds (BPER) are co-hosted by the Centre for Faculty DevelopmentThe Wilson Centre and the Centre for Interprofessional Education.

Our Best Practice in Education Rounds (BPER) are accredited group learning activities as defined by the Maintenance of Certification Program of The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. They are also accredited group learning activities as defined by the College of Family Physicians and Surgeons.

For more information about BPER, please click here.

Title

Program Evaluation as Contested: Can we Navigate Tensions for Transformative Practice?

Similar events

Paula Rowland will outline various forms of patient engagement in health professions education and will shed new light on the dilemma of representation.

More Information

When wellness is fostered, professional values and teaching excellence are celebrated; when misconduct and mistreatment are labelled and addressed, excellence through equity becomes achievable. Leaders in Temerty Medicine will share collaborative efforts that collectively strive to create healthy and braver learning environments.

More Information

A critical qualitative examination into people’s experiences of gender detransition/retransition in Canada

More Information

A critical qualitative examination into people’s experiences of gender detransition/retransition in Canada

More Information

Failure is a powerful teacher. But, instead of waiting for it to happen spontaneously during training, health professions educators are thinking deeply about "designing for failure" or "allowing failure" to deliberately harness its potential in instructional and clinical settings. During these rounds, the speakers will discuss two examples using failure in health professions education.

More Information

In this presentation the speaker will 1) offer a brief historical overview of evidence based medicine (EBM) with a focus on what it means to practice EBM and what role health professions education plays in helping realize EBM’s core aims; 2) explore whether the teaching of EBM needs to change to reflect changes in clinical practice and education since the movement’s inception. The speaker will then offer avenues that may be pursued that encompass a renewed agenda for teaching EBM.

More Information

There is much discussion of 'best evidence' or 'best practices' as a way of sharing and making use of the wisdom and experience of others. In this session we will consider the contextual and constrained nature of evidence and practice, the importance of considering context and contingency, and the ways in which scholars and practitioners may be equipped to think differently about problems and their solutions in the education of tomorrow's physicians and health care practitioners.

More Information

Please join us for BPER Reads, our annual "Battle of the Papers" where Beck McNeil and Jordan Holmes will each champion which paper of 2023 is the one paper all health professional educators must read.

More Information

In this BPER, we will tap into our own lived experiences to better understand our individual and collective motivations to engage in health equity work, and we will explore the possibilities of working together, today, to help create a healthier, more just world for all.

More Information

A review of some of the hypes and hopes associated with technology-enhanced medical education - from e-learning and simulation to AI-augmented learning.

More Information

In this talk, the speaker will use a critical feminist lens and relational cultural theory to contextualise why love is dismissed and perceived as deviant and threatening in higher education spaces, and invite us to envision what love, as a transformative practice, can offer health professions education, and indeed, ourselves.

More Information

In this presentation, we'll discuss the what, why, and where of humility through a brief history of the concept and how it relates specifically to healthcare and health professions education.

More Information

Please participate in BPER Reads, our annual "Battle of the Papers"! We begin this October with 5 scholars championing one paper of the past academic year they feel every health professional educator must read.

More Information

This talk will aim to provide participants with a fundamental understanding of Adaptive Expertise. Additionally, it will explore how workplace-based learning can promote adaptive practices that prepare physicians to effectively handle new situations and knowledge.

More Information

In this presentation, Dr. LeBlanc will describe the state of research on the relationship between emotions and the cognitive skills required for learning and patient care, followed by a discussion about the implications for health professions education and strategies to support learning during emotionally-laden learning situations.

More Information

In this talk, Dr. Laura Nimmon will describe her research studies that reveal the powerful influence of social structures occurring in the educational and professional practices of the health professions. This body of work widens the scope of our collective vision beyond learners and healthcare providers as independent with distinct expertise.

More Information

How will AI transform what it means to be an expert healthcare professional? Join the conversation to explore how health professions educators can prepare the next generation for a world where expertise extends across human-AI partnerships, and where effective patient care emerges from the thoughtful orchestration of both human and artificial intelligence.

More Information

This rounds will presented by members of the CFD Mentorship Community of Practice and will showcase the breadth and diverse nature of mentoring programs being delivered across the University of Toronto university, departments and hospitals.

More Information

Drawing from his diverse background in frontline medicine, public education, and his work at Apple, Dr. Evans will explore and untangle the evolving landscape of patient engagement and its implications for health professions education.

More Information